NY Pizza Suprema

If you’ve ever wandered the bustling streets of New York City (NY), chances are you’ve caught a whiff of freshly baked cheese pizza wafting through the air. It’s an irresistible aroma that pulls you toward one of the city’s most iconic establishments: NY Pizza Suprema. Nestled on 8th Avenue, this pizzeria is a treasure trove for pizza lovers, serving up a quintessential slice of New York-style pie. Whether you're a seasoned local or a tourist searching for the perfect bite, Pizza Suprema offers a mix of nostalgia, flavor, and history.

 

Let’s dive into everything you need to know about this legendary spot, from how to get there to the history behind its rise to fame.

 

What to Know

Nestled at 413 8th Ave, near Penn Station, this family restaurant is famous not only in York, NY but also beyond it. This small shop was founded in 1964 and serves probably the most delicious pies in the city, earning the recognition of critics and people.

 

Be it a plain cheese pizza or a proper Sicilian pizza with a thick base and a variety of toppings; Pizza Suprema delivers it all. They get good ingredients such as importing Pecorino Romano cheese to prepare pizzas that are traditional and at the same time trendy.

 

How to Get There

Getting to Pizza Suprema couldn’t be easier:

 

By Subway:

You can use A, C, E, or 1, 2, or 3 trains towards 34th Street – Penn Station. The pizzeria is conveniently located on 8th Avenue and is in front of the station.

 

By Bus:

The nearby bus stations include the M34 and M20 bus lines.

 

By Foot:

For instance, if you are already in Midtown Manhattan, a few steps from Madison Square Garden or the High Line, you will find this pizza empire.

 

Highlights

What makes the NY Pizza Suprema special among hundreds of pizzerias in New York?

 

Signature Cheese Pizza

As for them, their cheese pizza is as close to perfection as one can possibly imagine. Filled with melted mozzarella cheese, a touch of olive oil, and a thin and crispy crust, it embodies the true meaning of New York-style pizza.

 

Sicilian Pizza

For those who would like to have a denser crust, then, the Sicilian pizza is recommended for you. It is made from a soft dough covered with a thick layer of tomato sauce and offered either with pepperoni or even quality imported Pecorino.

 

Creative Toppings

As you will learn from reading the menu, Pizza Suprema does not only know how to come up with inventive toppings (truffle oil, fresh basil?) but also how to stay faithful to the classics (pepperoni, mushrooms).

 

Slice Harvester Seal of Approval

Pizza Suprema has recently received recognition from famous pizza lover and the author of the Slice Harvester blog. If that’s good enough for him, good enough for all of us.

 

Features

 

Family-Owned and Operated:

Most people love to have the feeling of supporting a business that has been in the family for many years.

 

Convenient Location:

Located right across Penn Station, the perfect slice of pizza to grab before catching a train is right here.

 

Affordable Prices:

Surprisingly, the prices are still quite mild, so it fits the bill for anyone and everyone.

 

Takeout and Dine-In Options:

For a fast meal or fine dining where you’ll take your time to savor each bite and chew Pizza Suprema has it all.

 

 

Best Time to Visit NY Pizza Suprema

The beauty of Pizza Suprema is that it is an any time of the year place. Here are some tips to enhance your visit:

 

Lunch Rush (11:30 AM – 2 PM):

Due to working people coming in for their coffee fix, it gives an exciting and busy town feel.

 

Late Night (10 PM-Midnight):

Ideal to take after coming from watching a Broadway show or a concert at Madison Square Garden.

 

Weekdays:

To reduce congestion, the recommended time to tour the area being in question is during the off-peak hours.

 

History of NY Pizza Suprema

The Pizza Suprema story started back in 1964 when an Italian migrant Salvatore Riggio opened the store and aimed to deliver NY-style pizza to the people. As time went by, valued customers became loyal customers, and people learned to appreciate the pizzeria for its commitment and adherence to the traditions.

 

They also have what many consider their groundbreaking year in 2005 when Slice Harvester included it in the list of its top pizzerias in the city. This placed Pizza Suprema on the map as far as fans of pizza from around the globe were concerned.

 

Nevertheless, Pizza Suprema has not changed its cooking style to adapt to its newer clients and new tendencies of New York, and it offers slices that adhere to its legendary history.

 

Other Must-Try Pizzas

While the cheese pizza and Sicilian pizza are the headliners, here are a few other menu items you should try:

 

White Pizza:

A vegetarian’s delight brushed with garlic and topped with freshly chopped tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and ricotta cheese, sprinkled with olive oil.

 

Grandma Slice:

Crispy with a thin and light texture, this pie is served with tomatoes, garlic, and spices added before cooking.

 

Veggie Supreme:

Filled with quick-cooking vegetables and has just enough of every taste bud-enthusing ingredient.

 

FAQs

Is NY Pizza Suprema Worth Visiting?

Absolutely! If you are an aficionado of Pizza, or just in need of a very traditional New York Pizza, Pizza Suprema does not disappoint.

 

What Makes NY Pizza Suprema Unique?

A commitment to using premium products such as imported Pecorino Romano cheese and its situation on Eighth Avenue puts it in a category of its own among New York’s hundreds of pizzerias.

 

Can I Order Slices or Whole Pies?

Both! Part of the beauty of Pizza Suprema is that, whether you are in a rush or simply have a passion for pizza, you may get it by the slice or a whole pie.

 

Is It Close to Other Attractions?

Yes, it is true that it is only a stone's throw away from Penn Station, Madison Square Garden, and other conspicuous landmarks in Midtown.

 

Pro Tips for Visiting

 

Try a Variety of Slices:

It is recommended not to stick with a particular type of pizza, order a bit of cheese pizza, Sicilian pizzas, and others.

 

Arrive Early:

During busy hours, which brings traffic to the line, it has a tendency to be long; however, it turns over quite rapidly.

 

Pair Your Pizza:

Accompany your slice with a glass of chilled Coke or find a good craft beer to enjoy it with.

 

Why NY Pizza Suprema Belongs on Your NYC Bucket List

Perhaps no other location captures the true essence of York, NY as lots of people know about NY Pizza Suprema. It is not simply a pizzeria, but a piece of the past that means a gathering place for the people of New York as well as visitors and an opportunity to taste what makes New York the pizza capital of the world.

 

Whether you’re a fan of thin crusts with a drizzle of olive oil or hearty, cheesy Sicilian pizza, Pizza Suprema is the kind of place you’ll find yourself returning to again and again. So next time you’re in the Big Apple, don’t just walk past it—step inside, grab a slice, and let the flavors speak for themselves.

 

Tripshepherd is your guide to uncovering hidden gems like NY Pizza Suprema. From day tours to private adventures, our New York tours help you explore the best of York, NY—one slice at a time.